Skip to content

docs(represent): close LOOP-1 and define PARETO-1's value-sensitive gate - #477

Draft
chrishayuk wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
represent-pareto-1
Draft

chrishayuk wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
represent-pareto-1

Conversation

@chrishayuk

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

REPRESENT-LOOP-1 is complete: A (#474), B (#475), and the paired C witness (#476) are reviewed and merged. This records C's merge at 23a56db1, after every workflow passed on ac892f2e, including both mutation jobs.

The next proposed experimental milestone is REPRESENT-PARETO-1: accepted quality values and grounded physical costs must change measured-candidate preference. Its primary control holds candidate keys, observed-key sets, cost facts and policy fixed across independent counterfactual replays, so AlreadyObserved cannot explain the result. It also requires a physical-cost control, replay determinism, transactional rejection and preservation of ambiguity when evidence cannot justify a winner.

The first-gate assumption is a tiny controlled fixture before real numerical measurements. Concrete numeric inputs, cost provenance and expected decisions must be frozen before implementation. This PR registers the claim and controls; it does not claim a PARETO result or implement a new policy.

The existing boundary is explicit: PhysicalPrizeFirst orders unmeasured experiments, while accepted quality values feed the measured-preference path. Generalizing to unseen neighbours and installing a promoted incumbent are separate claims. Existing K3 authority debts remain recorded.

Validation: all milestone JSON parses; 105 contract witnesses, 867 relative documentation links and 1,448 strict references pass; git diff --check passes. Documentation only.

Completed milestone · PARETO-1 design

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant